The $5,356 Problem: Why Two-Thirds of First-Time Buyers Face Unexpected Costs
66% of first-time buyers face unexpected issues averaging $5,356 after closing. Learn what causes post-closing surprises and how to protect yourself.
A 2024 survey of over 1,000 homeowners revealed a troubling pattern in first-time home purchases. The numbers tell a story about what happens when buyers feel pressured to move fast in competitive markets - and the financial consequences that follow.
The Numbers
Two-thirds (66%) of first-time buyers encountered unexpected issues after closing on their homes. The average cost to fix these issues: $5,356.
Beyond the immediate financial hit, the survey revealed deeper problems:
- 38% felt rushed into their purchase decision
- Rushed buyers were nearly 3x more likely to experience buyer remorse
- 17% skipped the home inspection entirely
- Among lower-income buyers (under $50K annually), 23% skipped inspections
- 31% of first-time buyers reported overall purchase regret
- 45% paid more than their original budget
The Pattern
The data reveals a predictable cascade:
- Buyer feels rushed or pressured by competitive market
- Due diligence gets shortened or skipped
- Problems in documents go unnoticed
- Issues surface after closing
- Buyer pays $5,356 on average to fix them
The emotional toll compounds the financial burden. The survey found that 34% of buyers felt overwhelmed during the process, 28% felt stressed, and 25% felt nervous. Over one-quarter said they lacked adequate financial knowledge when purchasing.
Where the Problems Hide
In most cases, the information that could have revealed these problems was available - somewhere in the transaction documents. Inspection reports flag structural concerns. Disclosure forms reveal known defects. HOA documents contain pending assessments.
But real estate transactions generate 300-600 pages of documents. When buyers feel rushed, they skim. When agents are juggling multiple deals, details slip through. When transaction coordinators are managing five or six files simultaneously, page 247 does not get the same attention as page 1.
The information was there. It just did not get surfaced in time.
What First-Time Buyers Should Do
If you are buying your first home, resist the pressure to cut corners on due diligence:
- Get the home inspection. Never waive it to make your offer more competitive. The $400-500 you spend could save you thousands.
- Read the disclosure forms carefully. Sellers are required to disclose known defects. Make sure you understand what they are telling you.
- If buying a condo or in an HOA, review the full package. Meeting minutes, reserve studies, financial statements - not just the CC&Rs.
- Ask questions. If something in the documents is unclear, ask your agent or attorney to explain it.
- Budget for the unexpected. Even with thorough due diligence, surprises happen. Have reserves available.
What Agents Should Do
For agents working with first-time buyers, the survey is a reminder that protecting your clients from post-closing surprises is part of the job. That means:
- Helping buyers resist pressure to waive inspections or rush decisions
- Ensuring documents are reviewed thoroughly, not just skimmed
- Explaining what the disclosure forms and inspection reports actually mean
- Setting realistic expectations about timeline and budget
The best deal is the one where your client still feels good about their purchase a year later - not the one that closed fastest.
CT
Sharing insights on transaction intelligence and real estate technology.